Cheness Sword Reviews Classic Review
The SGG Katana

Extra WIDE Blade...!

The SGC stands for 'specialized Goza cutter'.

What's a Goza I hear you ask?

Well, it's what we usually call 'Tatami mats' - the rollable covers that are used to make tatami flooring in Japan. They say that a single mat rolled up tightly and soaked overnight in water roughly replicas a human limb (comparing it, apparently, in an earlier time when the Shogunate issued an edict to stop testing on peasants, so the Samurai had to find other, approximate targets!)

And this sword is supposedly designed for maximum Goza cutting power.

Either way, this thing is a monster of a blade, and while it's heft and intimidating profile will turn many off it, a few will be drawn to it like months to a flame..


Cheness Cutlery SGC Katana Review

Review by SBG Editor in Chief, Paul Southren


Steel 

Weight 

Point of Balance 

Price Range

9260 Spring Steel

2lbs 15oz

6" from tsuba

US$299

It sounds a little bit like the 'SBG Katana' I know. And when I first laid eyes on it, I actually thought it had a bit of 'SBG style' about it: it was big, it was overbuilt and it felt like a monster..

I took an immediate liking to it, and like many who have picked it up before and after my initial review have re-iterated, my first thoughts upon picking it up were:

"This THING is a beast!!"

Now I tested mine out soon after this series was released in late 2006 - and at the time there were two variants available. Mine was called the 'Tsukikage' (moon shadow) but was phased out in favor of the Yamakami (山神) - either way the blades were the same, the only difference is in the fittings.

Now if you have read any of our other Cheness reviews you will know that fittings are not Cheness Cutleries strong point. They readily admit to this, but naturally a sword is only as strong as it's weakest point, so before we did ANYTHING with this monster of a blade, we had to check the fittings.

Because the one I selected was the one discontinued (oh well) here's a pic of the parts dismantled by one of our SBG forumites.

It's nothing so fancy, a wider than usual wooden tsuka with brown cotton ito wrap, a blackened steel Mt Fuji tsuba and other standard fittings on a roughly filed, broad full tang.

Certainly nothing to write home about. But the overall feel and heft of the sword is. I'll let the forumite who took this pic take over for a moment, as he describes his overall impressions of this sword as below:

I got my yamakami a couple of weeks ago and as soon as i picked up the cardboard box i knew that there was something special inside, it immediately felt heavier...

...Upon removal and after taking off the grease I think the first thought that came to mind was "oh my god what a beast"!

This really is a beautiful katana and the extra weight, 3lbs 13oz with saya and 2lbs 15oz without by my scales, really does not make much difference to the handling after a few minutes and before anything else i just had to go outside and dispatch some water bottles and a few willow saplings then straight on to some double and triple mats, what a pleasure and so easy....”

So the big question is, just how well does it really cut? Let's look at it from a few different angles and try to answer..

Cutting Tests

There were two parts to my own cutting tests - the first was to make sure that the SGC could actually do what it was supposed to do - that is cut tatami mats properly.

And the second one was to determine if the broader, thinner blade was as STRONG as the other Cheness 9260 Spring Steel Katana.

Essentially, the blade profile of the SGC is similar to that of the Practical XL by the Hawei forge, but on steriods.

While the XL is quite fast and like a giant scalpel, the SGC is - well, it just feels like a monster of a thing. But while it takes a bit more muscle, in the right hands it's no big deal.

The first proof of it's cutting ability was demonstrated by Cheness Cutleries Paul Chen in a backyard cutting video where he cuts single, double and triple mats.

VIDEO: Cheness Testing Vid

The testing video by Cheness Inc with single, double and triple mats. Plus outtakes.

My only problem was, I did not have many tatami mats at the time - they are really quite expensive - especially as I was living in Australia at the time, so I did the best I could and rolled a double mat..

It was much bigger than I expected it to be. But this was to be an 'out of the box' test and while the blade felt quite sharp, I didn't know if the blade would make it all the way through.

VIDEO: SBG Testing Vid

It was, all in all, surprisingly easy to cut..

So far so good. But what about lighter targets like water filled bottles?

After all, this sword was heavy but the angle of entry was quite narrow, so as long as it was balanced well enough to achieve maximum velocity, light targets should be no problem...

Accordingly, I set up a few water filled buddy bottles and hung them from the clothes line.

VIDEO: P.E.T. Bottle Cutting

Hardly graceful, I ended up getting just a tad wetter than I planned

As you can see, the first cut was pretty much spot on perfect. The second one went through a little further than I intended, spraying water everywhere and skimming the bottom of the third bottle and slicing it open so that the water started to flow out.

And in an attempt to hit it before it was empty, I struck a little too fast – and covered myself and my friend who was filming in water!

As I said, not the most graceful blade on the market. But it could cut bottles out of the box with no problem either.

As such, there was one final question. Was the narrower blade more fragile than the swords I have tested in previous SBG Cheness Sword Reviews?

Time to break out the old 2x4..

VIDEO: Testing on a 2x4

Nice deep cuts and no edge deformation

It passed the test with flying colors, hacking deep into the wood with no apparent blunting to the blade, chips or other damage. Not something I would want to do with the XL - but that doesn't necessarily make it better.

Conclusion

The SGC certainly does cut Goza extremely well - but while it is a beast it still has what it takes to cut light targets like water filled bottles and enough durability to take on a 2x4..

But does it necessarily cut so much better than a normal blade? After all, while not all blades can cut triple mats (most can't - even some of the super expensive ones) the better ones can - and at a certain point you face the law of diminishing returns as beyond 3 mats blade drag is a major factor, and the wider the blade, the more it drags..

All I can say with certainty is that it is BIG, it is MEAN and it is most certainly STRONG. A very interesting addition to any collection and with a massive intimidation factor, but while I like it very much, it probably would not be my first recommendation for a beginner.

But if it speaks to you, get it. I'm pretty sure you will like it..

PROS

  • Effective and very durable cutter
  • It's a BEAST of a thing and looks quite terrifying to behold
CONS
  • Perhaps not the most graceful Katana on the market...
  • Fittings are average at best

WHERE TO BUY

The SCG Katana is available exclusively from the manufacturer and right here SBG Sword Store for $299.


I hope this review of the Cheness SGC Katana was helpful. To return to The Best Japanese Sword for under $300 is MONOTEMPERED from Cheness Sword Reviews Classic Review: The SGC Katana, click here

Looking for honest, trustworthy sword sellers? Look no further than:

The Official SBG Sword Buyers Directory!

Sword Buyers Digest Newsletter!

Sign Up Now

Sign Up to Our FREE Monthly E-zine for all the latest sword news, info and much, much more! Click Here for more info..

Popular Review Categories

From the Store

If you like swords, "like" our page..!