1050 vs 9260 Spring Steel

by mike tong
(Evansville,IN USA)

QUESTION: Can you tell me the different between 1050 spring steel (cold steel katana) and 9260 spring steel (cheness Tenchi) which steel is more stronger?

I know your website don't have cold steel katana, but I'm with cheness Tenchi all the way.

Thanks.
Mike

ANSWER: Hi Mike,

The 9260 Spring Steel (and specifically, how well it is tempered by Cheness) is a lot more resiliant and tougher than Cold Steels 1050.

On the whole, most Cold Steel swords are tempered very well, but tend to be a bit thick. The Cheness 9260 gets the same and a better toughness without needing such a beefy blade, so the end result is - 9260 is the best in terms of durability. I really haven't seen anything else out there in this price range that comes close.

Hope this helps.

- Paul

Comments for 1050 vs 9260 Spring Steel

Click here to add your own comments

1050 spring steel imperial forge
by: Barry Harman (UK)

Hello Mike
I notice you website doesn't review imperial forge katana's. Despite that i bought one and although the sword looks good the blade has no apparent hamon. And the blade doesn't seem that sharp. Is that expected or have i picked a bum blade? would have gone with your recomendations, but not much choice in the UK.
Cheers great website!

edge retention
by: Anonymous

so 9260 is definitely tougher then 1050, but does it hold an edge as well? are there pros & cons to each one?

Input
by: Caleb

9260 has the capability to be a harder blade. The silicon alloy increases shock resistance and if tempered correctly is a superior material. That being said heat treating is everything. I've produced blades in both I prefer 9160 and 5160 for durability and spring. However I would recommend through hardened steel over other tempering methods. With modern steel and modern heat control you actually lose functionality for aesthetic. And remember a sword above all must be a reliable tool.

Cheness produces some well tempered blades. Descent for intro level. The fittings are sub par and the blades are a bit meaty and incorrectly shaped. Thé habaki are non historically fit to the blade. Tsuka had to be replaced due to cracking

Cold steel the blades are overly hearty. I have never tested their blades to failure so I won't vouch for quality.

9260 ebay????
by: charly

i already find some 9260 spring steel katanas on ebay they sold them for 99 to 150, do you know something about them?? are they good as the cheness??

steel
by: k60

For a fully functioal sword or knife 5160 and 9260cm are the best -super tough- able to hold an edge and keep it- easy to sharpen- most smiths that know what their doing love working with it-they are corrosion resistant without losing strength - with proper heat treating i would even say they are better than welding/ folding/laminated super expensive jap swords but thats opinion and ive never seen a destructive test to put this question to bed but would love to see a 20k katana swing and meet a 5160th 300$ katana until we found which broke first- but the odds of that happening are a million to 1. so we'll never truly know.

steel
by: k60

5160 and 9260th will have an outer hc of 55 to 60and a core softness of around 30 heat treated properly which gives it the same characteristics as the laminated high $ blades without all the microscopic welding flaws ........K.I.S.S

9260
by: Anonymous

can anyone tell me the proper heat treatment for 9260 spring steel . any tips would be appriceated and is it a forgiving metal? im going to atempt to build a knifed from it in a charcoal forge. thanks for any advice.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Ask Questions About Japanese Swords.