There aren't that many affordable Chinese broad swords on the market. Sure, if you are willing to spend well over US$300 the market opens up and there are some spectacular pieces available. But under $300, and the choices are generally limited to either thin and whippy Wushu style swords or stainless steel clunkers...
Enter the Practical Kung fu sword (SH2063) by the Hanwei Forge.
With a recommended retail price of US$250 (though available
for under US$200 if you know where to look), it certainly fit the bill
as far as price goes.
But the big question was, were these Chinese broad swords going to perform as a cutting practice sword? Lets find out shall we!
Review by Paul Southren (Ed), Adelaide, AUSTRALIA
According to renowned Chinese sword expert Scott Rodell:
The Ox Tail is a saber favored for less skilled swordsmen because it can deliver a more powerful cut than the Willow Leaf of Goose Quill Sabers. In other words, if you're removing pounds of flesh, its less important where you cut. Accordingly, it was favored by martial artists with less time for training, ie peasants, tradesmen, etc. vs. professional military, body guards and so on.
As such, fitting the less skilled swordsman category and liking a sword that can "deliver a more powerful cut" than the other Chinese Broad Swords - I felt that the Practical Kung fu sword was definitely for me! ;-)
This is a very simple, and as the name suggests, practical sword.
The fittings are blackened steel and with no special details or embellishments. The pommel is curved in the opposite direction to the blade, which is traditional with ox tail Chinese broad swords and features a small fixed point ring for attaching a tassel if so desired.
As you will see in a moment, this ring can be unscrewed to get some rudimentary access under the hilt...
The hilt itself is snugly assembled, and is a brown lacquered woodgrain design that at first I was sure was made of plastic... Over the handles core is a latticework of very attractively done knotting which is nicely executed and looks quite authentic.
The only problem with this covering is that it does not grip the smoothly finished core very tightly and tends to shift a little in the hand when swinging it, and can get a little annoying if you want it to sit perfectly...
Anyway, dissembling this Chinese broad swords hilt I found to be an impossible task. The ring nut on the pommel can be unscrewed with some lubricant and pliers, and the pommel itself can be removed revealing that the core is indeed wood and not plastic like I first suspected.
However, the rest of the assembly is epoxied into the handle and cannot be removed without destroying it. While this is of course not an ideal (or traditional!) construction it is acceptable at this price point and is reassuring to know that the assembly is highly unlikely to ever come loose.
The scabbard is quite simple, wooden with a brown and textured lacquer and black steel accents at the chape, throat and two points along the length including one with a two ringed belt attachment assembly. However, the thing I REALLY dont like about the scabbard is the slotted opening.
In their official descriptions of these Chinese broad swords, Hanwei states: The textured wooden scabbard is designed with a slotted opening, which makes both for easy sheathing and graceful lines.
While it may ostensibly be designed to give the scabbard a nice curve the slot extends more than two thirds of the way down the length of the blade and means that to draw it, the blade is half falling out and in my opinion makes the whole thing quite useless...
However, all these niggling issues pretty much fade into insignificance once you finally catch side of the blade...
Measuring in at an impressive 28, one look at this blade and you can see it means business!
The finish of the blade is utilitarian, with a satiny two toned polish that is distinctively whitish on the part of the blade that tapers to the razor edge.
With a fuller at the back down around 1/3 of its length and the classic Ox Tail profile, this Chinese broad swords blade has a very clear and finely shaped distal tapering profile, starting at .18 thick at the handle and terminating in a tip half that with a smooth transition along its length.
Quite thin, yet much stiffer than the typical Wushu swords it has an impressive temper to it and flexes nicely, springing back quickly and sharply without any undue wobbling you can tell straight away that these Chinese broad swords are truly optimised for seriously powerful, shearing cuts.
But perhaps what struck me the most about this sword was just how darn sharp it was out of the box. This thing is literally scalpel sharp and there is no doubt that running your finger along it would slice you to the bone.
Naturally, with such a thin and sharp blade it passed the paper cutting test with ease.
These Chinese broad swords are A WHOLE HEAP OF FUN to handle.
Weighing in at just 1lb 10oz, it is perhaps 4oz lighter than traditional Ox Tail Chinese Broad Swords, but balanced at exactly 8 from the guard it handles exactly like one of these swords should, with a little extra speed.
In the hand, it is a very lively sword and transitioning from one cut to another is almost too easy especially when you consider that a mistake with this blade could easily slice off an ear or take off several fingers in a row. Because of my respect for its cutting abilities (especially after the tests which you will see in a moment) I have yet to realize its true handling capabilities, but suffice it to say that this sword far exceeds my own technical knowledge of Chinese sword fighting but in the hands of an expert it would be truly terrifying to behold...
I cannot remember the exact order I performed these cutting tests in. The reason why was that this sword was just sooo much fun to cut with, I just kept looking for another suitable target for it and was barely able to film everything in my usual calm and pseudo-scientific manner...! ;-)
So rather than give too many written explanations at this point, Ill let the videos do the talking!
The first target was designed to test its sharpness, speed and to a lesser extent my (lack of) accuracy. So target # 1 was 5 water filled Milk jugs set up on a table.
As you can see from the video above - the Practical Kung fu sword sliced through them all despite my poor technique, pickle chipping them on the second swipe.
Next I am pretty sure that I set up three hanging buddy bottles. This turned out to be one of the most interesting cutting results of them all...
I was expecting that this Chinese broad swords blade would cut through them like a laser. But what I liked the most was the metallic twanging sound of the thin steel blade reverberating as it strikes the bottle.
Since putting this videos on YouTube I've got comments that people would buy this sword for this sound alone and I tend to concur! It is definitely a nice sound and something that can get very addictive!
The next test I was not so sure of. But I needn't have worried. Against a cardboard box, one slice and the result is two perfect halves. Indeed, this is one of the cleanest cuts I have executed with any sword and not a single visible scratch on the blades surface. Nice.
With all of the light to medium targets out of the way, there remained one last medium available for me on the day. Tatami Mats.
Needless to say, as you can see in the video the razor sharp laser keen edge made short work of tatami...
By the end of it, I certainly had more than a healthy respect for this sword. And All in all, as a light and fast cutter, it more than does the job!
Because the edge is so thin, I wouldnt really want to test these Chinese broad swords on any mediums much harder than those shown above. I have little doubt that it could handle green bamboo (though it was not available for these tests). And Ive used it against some light tree branches and leaves, and in each case it cuts with surgical precision with damage or blunting of the razor edge whatsoever.
If I had to sum this sword up in a few words it would be nice sword, GREAT cutter - crap scabbard.
It handles like a dream. It is ridiculously sharp. And it cuts through everything I have put in front of it like butter.
In short, these Chinese broad swords are immensely good fun and it is actually one of the cleanest cutting swords I have handled to date.
With the right kind of blade weight, balance and strength for real martial arts applications, it certainly lives up to its name. Highly recommended for cutting fun and martial arts training, with such a keen cutting edge, youd want to be very precise with these Chinese broad swords if you were practicing Kung fu forms otherwise youd quickly find just how practical these swords really are...
Despite the minor cosmetic issues with the handle and the awful scabbard, this sword has a two thumbs up from me.
I hope this review of Hanwei's Chinese Broad swords has been helpful. To return to Fully Functional Yet Inexpensive Chinese Swords from, Hanweis Chinese Broad Swords , click here