Apr 01, 23 02:27 AM
What's a real katana price? (notice we said didn't say "real katanas price" as katana is both the plural and singular form).
Can you guess how much the three swords above are worth? Are they real, or do you think they are "fake"?
Believe it or not, if you see blades in this plain fit out called "Shirasaya" it is quite possible that they are VERY valuable..
Indeed, the starting real katana price for a bona fide sword made in Japan (called a "Nihonto" or "Shinken", meaning "Japan sword" and "real sword" accordingly) is around US$4,000 - such as the one shown below which was made in 2015 (a second hand "Shinsakuto" - sword made in the modern period after WWII) and costs just a tad over $4,400.
Bear in mind that this is the STARTING price.
An average price is around 70-90万円, 700,000 yen. Roughly US$6,500-8,000 for a recently made piece. Here are a couple more...
When it comes to the real Katana vs fake debate, some purists argue that the only real Katana Nihonto made in Japan costing over $4,000 (you can buy cheap wallhangers in Japan made from zinc aluminum alloy for around $100, but real sword production is strictly regulated - Japan has some of the toughest weapon ownership laws in the world - and so anyone buying a sword in Japan for that kind of price is not getting a real sword of course..)
However, let's define what we mean by "real"..
If we define real as hand made, with a real hamon temper line from hand claying, extremely sharp, well balanced, with high quality fittings and able to cut like a lightsaber - then there can be no argument that the differences between the two blades below are really down the extra attention to detail, WHO made them and WHERE they are manufactured...
In the argument of real Katana vs fake, leaving out WHERE they are made and judging them purely on form and function - the reality is that both of these swords are fairly close.
Some people think so because there is no doubt that more attention to detail is paid to this blade than the Chinese made one.
But for practical purposes, the differences are actually pretty minor..
So back to our original question, how much is the Shirasaya set in the first picture worth?
The set in the picture are worth - around US$50 for the lot.. But from the picture alone, even an expert might not know if they were real Nihonto or not..
The only way to know if what you are seeing on the internet is a real katana price or not is the REPUTATION of the company offering it. A trustworthy sword seller is honest about where the swords are made, how they are made, and who makes them..
Bad sellers, not so much.. The worst I have seen is a brand (that will remain unnamed for now) that claims their swords are made in "Seki city Japan" - but we actually found them stored away on a visit to Longquan, China..! They are being sold for $900 but should sell for $200 at best - so beware, there are some real sharks out there!
So when it comes to Japanese swords, especially high end ones, it pays to do your research. Use SBG, visit sword forums, ask lots of questions, and get to know your brands..
Or of course, just go to Japan with $4-10K and buy there - because according to the purists, that is the real katana price you will need to pay! (though money alone is not always enough, many traditional sellers need to get to know you personally to ensure the sword will be looked after and going to a good home! Yes, they take their swords THAT seriously!)..
We only just touch on the real Katana price of swords made in Japan here - but if you want to dig a LOT deeper into the current state of affairs with sword making in Japan, check out my article 'Antique Samurai Swords: A Personal Journey In Japan'
In it, I document a pivitol trip to Seki city in Japan - the capital of sword and knife production there - and provide insight into the state of the sword making industry in Japan, take a close look at some very affordable antiques, and discuss plans for a future collaboration with a smith who is the last of his school (plus enjoy a truly delicious gourmet Teriyaki burger!)
I hope this article on the real katana prices has been helpful. To return to The Ultimate Guide to Authentic Japanese Swords from Real Katana Prices, click here